Is Hunters Creek a Good Place to Live? The 2026 Numbers

Hunter's Creek in plain numbers

Is Hunters Creek a good place to live in 2026? For Orlando buyers in the $400,000 to $700,000 range, the short answer is yes. The longer answer is that Hunter's Creek behaves like three different neighborhoods inside one master plan, and the right pick depends on commute, school zone, and how much HOA stack you can stomach on top of the mortgage.

The May 2026 Redfin median sale was $533K, up 20.5% year over year, with homes spending 40 days on the market. That puts Hunter's Creek roughly 30% above the broader Orlando metro median near $410K and inside the price band where buyers also weigh Lake Nona, Dr. Phillips, and Horizon West. For a wider city read, see our take on whether Orlando overall is a good place to live.

What follows is a numbers-first read for buyers, renters, and relocating households. Cost, schools, taxes, HOA stacking, commute math, and the two mistakes that cost the most. If you are moving from out of state, pair this guide with the Pozek Group Orlando Relocation Guide for the bigger picture.

---

The full breakdown of price, fees, schools, and commute times is below.

Metric	Detail
Median sale price (May 2025)	$533K per Redfin
Median price per sq ft	$260
Year-over-year price change	+20.5%
Median days on market	40
Population	about 22,800 (Niche)
Distance to MCO airport	9.5 miles, 15 to 20 minutes via SR-417
Distance to Walt Disney World	8 to 10 miles, 15 to 20 minutes off-peak
Distance to downtown Orlando	About 17 miles, 20 to 25 minutes off-peak
Master HOA base fee	$175 a month
Sub-association range	$271 to $660 (condo); $312 to $335 (townhome)
School zone (OCPS)	Hunter's Creek Elem (A-), Hunter's Creek Middle (B+), Freedom High (A-)
On-site golf	Hunter's Creek Golf Club at Osprey Links, semi-private

---

---

What it actually costs in Hunters Creek

$533K is the May 2025 Redfin median sale figure for Hunter's Creek, with a median of $260 per square foot and 40 days on market. That is the headline number, but the real picture lives inside the spread.

Condo phases at Osprey Links and Bristol Bay still close in the low $200,000s for 1,000 to 1,200 square foot two-bedroom units. Attached townhomes in Calabay Point and Stonebridge Lakes hover near $375,000 for 1,500 to 1,800 square feet. Detached single-family homes range from $475,000 for a 1,900 square foot tile-roof home built in 1995 up to $900,000 for newer pool homes backing the golf course.

Math on a homesteaded primary at the May 2025 median: a 20% down loan at 6.75% on a 30-year fixed prices the principal and interest at $2,768 a month. Orange County unincorporated millage at 18.1 mills on the same assessed value with the $50,000 homestead exemption runs $8,732 a year, or $728 a month. Insurance on a 1995-era home with a recent roof averages $3,200 a year, or $267 a month. Master HOA at $175 a month brings the PITIA total to about $3,938 a month before any sub-association fee. Lender 28% gross income guidance puts the qualifying salary at $169,000.

Most buyers underweight the HOA stack. A condo phase with a $660 monthly sub-fee plus the $175 master fee adds $835 a month, or $10,020 a year. That is a third payment hiding behind the listing price, so always run total cost of ownership before falling for the per-square-foot number.

The roof and HOA mistakes that cost buyers most

Most buyers picture Hunter's Creek as new construction. It is not. The first phases opened in 1986 and the bulk of the single-family build-out happened between 1992 and 2002. That makes roof age the single biggest insurance variable and the most common offer-killer at the inspection table.

Florida insurers price Hunters Creek roofs in five-year tiers. A 0 to 10 year roof gets the best rate. An 11 to 20 year roof loses several discounts. A roof past 25 years often kicks the home into surplus lines coverage at $5,500 to $7,200 a year, or it triggers a non-renewal letter mid-policy. The fix is simple: ask for the roof permit date on day one and price replacement into your offer if it sits over 20 years.

The second mistake is HOA stacking. Hunter's Creek runs a two-tier system. The $175 monthly master HOA covers the parks, trails, and community fitness center. Then each sub-village runs its own association on top.

Real example: a 2-bed condo at Bristol Bay listed at $215K looks like a starter. Pull the disclosure and you find a $522 monthly sub-fee, which adds $6,264 a year. On the same condo, dropping to a townhome at $375K with a $312 sub-fee saves $2,520 a year in HOA, which more than offsets the bigger mortgage. Always pull the resale package before you write the offer.

What daily life looks like in the master plan

You wake up at 6:45 AM in a Calabay Point home, grab coffee, and merge onto SR-417 at the Hunter's Creek exit by 7:15. Twenty minutes later you are at the MCO terminal curb. That commute is the single biggest lifestyle advantage of living here.

The community sits across roughly 4,000 acres east of John Young Parkway and south of the Beachline. Three community parks anchor the master plan: Hunter's Creek Community Park on Town Loop Boulevard, Osprey Park near the golf club, and Catfish Pond Park on the south side. Paved trails connect most sub-villages and link to the Shingle Creek Trail system to the south.

Daily errands cluster at the Loop and Loop West shopping centers, about 10 to 12 minutes north on John Young Parkway. Publix at Hunter's Creek Village on Town Center Boulevard handles the weekly grocery run. Restaurants worth knowing: Boca Kitchen, Bar, and Market in the Loop, and a string of South Asian and Latin American spots on West Sand Lake Road that locals call Restaurant Row.

Hunter's Creek Golf Club at Osprey Links is the community signature. It is a semi-private 18-hole par 72 designed by Lloyd Clifton and Ken Ezell, with rounds running $45 to $75 depending on season. Many homes on Town Loop Boulevard and Hunter Vista Boulevard sit on the course, which lifts pricing 8% to 14% over comparable lots without water or fairway views.

---

Hunter's Creek vs other south Orlando communities

Neighborhood	Median Price	Vibe	HOA Range	Best For
Hunter's Creek	$533K	Established 1990s master plan	$175 master plus $271 to $660 sub	Schools, MCO commute, golf
Lake Nona	$589K	New build, Medical City employer	$80 to $310	Tech jobs, USTA, newer construction
Dr. Phillips	$700K	Mature, tourist corridor	$0 to $400	Sand Lake dining, A-rated schools
Horizon West	$595K	Suburban sprawl, Disney adjacent	$50 to $200 plus CDD	New construction, theme parks
Windermere proper	$1.1M	Lakefront luxury, low density	$200 to $1,000	Luxury, lake access, privacy

Hunter's Creek wins on airport access and price stability. It sits below Lake Nona on median sale price, well below Dr. Phillips and Windermere, and offers the shortest established-suburb commute to MCO at 9.5 miles. The trade-off is housing stock age. Lake Nona and Horizon West give you new construction with builder warranties; Hunter's Creek gives you 1995 to 2005 inventory with maintenance debt the seller may or may not have addressed.

If you want detached single-family at the lowest qualifying salary inside the south Orlando employment zone, Hunter's Creek still leads. If you want the lowest possible HOA stack, look at Hunter's Creek detached homes only (not condos or townhomes) or shift to Horizon West and accept the CDD assessment in exchange for a flatter monthly fee.

---

Schools and the numbers buyers ask about

Between 1995 and 2010 Orange County built out the Hunters Creek school cluster to keep pace with the master plan. Today three elementaries, one middle, and one high school feed the community. Niche grades, which weigh test scores, college outcomes, and parent reviews, give Hunter's Creek Elementary an A-, West Creek Elementary a B+, Endeavor Elementary a B, Hunter's Creek Middle a B+, and Freedom High an A-.

Hunter's Creek Middle is the standout. Niche ranks it #8 among standout middle schools in the Orlando area, with 79% math proficiency and 57% reading proficiency on state tests. The student to teacher ratio sits at 20 to 1 across 1,112 students in grades 6 through 8. Renaissance Charter School at Hunters Creek serves as a K through 8 alternative with a Niche B grade and 1,538 students.

Boundaries matter inside the master plan. The Hunter's Creek Elementary attendance zone covers the central and northern sub-villages near Town Loop Boulevard. West Creek Elementary picks up the southwest sub-villages. Endeavor Elementary covers the southeast Calabay Point side. Always pull the OCPS attendance boundary map by exact address, because a single street can flip you between the A- school and the B school.

The real tax and insurance bill in Hunters Creek

Closing in Hunter's Creek means writing two checks the listing price never mentions: an Orange County tax bill and a homeowners insurance policy that has tripled for some sellers since 2020. Florida has no state income tax, but property tax and insurance carry that load in full.

Orange County millage for unincorporated areas like Hunter's Creek runs about 18.1 mills in 2025. On a primary home assessed at $533K with the $50,000 homestead exemption, the taxable value is $483K and the annual property tax is $8,732. Drop the assessed value to $400K and the same math gives a tax bill of $6,332. On a non-homesteaded investment property at the same assessed value, the annual tax climbs to $9,647 because none of the $50,000 exemption applies.

Homeowners insurance pricing in 2026 depends on three variables: roof age, opening protection, and the four-point report. A 1996 home with a 2019 roof, no impact glass, and a clean four-point typically prices around $3,200 a year. The same home with a 2002 roof spikes to $5,400 a year, and most carriers refuse to write a new policy at all. A wind mitigation inspection at $75 to $150 can return $500 to $2,500 in annual savings if the home has any qualifying features.

Closing math on a 20% down purchase at the May 2025 median: about $5,540 in typical buyer closing costs plus the $853 intangible tax on the mortgage. Total cash to close lands near $112,150 including the $106,600 down payment. Sellers at the same price pay the deed documentary stamp of $3,731 and standard commission and title charges.

---

8 tips for buying in Hunters Creek

• Pull the roof permit date before you write the offer. This single data point drives insurance pricing more than every other variable combined. A roof past 20 years can lift annual insurance by $2,000 to $4,000 or push the home into non-admitted carriers.
• Read the sub-association resale package before falling for the sticker price. The $175 master fee is just the floor.
• Order a wind mitigation inspection within 14 days. A $125 inspection returns $500 to $2,500 a year if the home has qualifying features.
• Confirm the school boundary by exact address using the OCPS Find Your School tool. A single street can flip you between the A- and B school.
• If you commute downtown, model the toll cost. SR-417 to SR-408 runs about $3.20 each way, or $1,600 a year.
• Avoid 1-story homes built before 1998 unless the seller has replaced cast iron drain stacks. Replumbing runs $8,000 to $18,000.
• Treat any condo built before 2001 as a special assessment risk. Florida SB 4-D reserve requirements have triggered $4,000 to $22,000 assessments at several phases.
• Negotiate the sub-fee capital contribution at closing. Some sub-villages charge a $1,500 to $2,500 transfer fee that is fully negotiable in this 40-day market.

---

---

Why Work with Pozek Group?

Pozek Group is the official real estate partner of the Orlando Magic, with the closed volume and local coverage to back a Hunter's Creek search.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

---

---